Introducing our latest offering – Tac-O – Get Ya Sum!
Homemade Cream Cheese

Scan here for a special Buy One, Get One FREE offer!

QR Code for BOGO offer

Homemade Cream Cheese

Flavors Used:

Get your bagels toasted, and get ready to schmear this mouthwatering homemade strawberry and jalapeno cream cheese! This is a fun recipe to try, you get a big old batch of fresh, tangy cream cheese schmear that you can flavor anyway you want. Perfect for making fruit flavored or more savory cream cheeses that are perfect for bagels, cheesecakes, or party dips! We recommend whipping up some plain, or with garlic and dill, for our mouthwatering Gravlax (Swedish Cured Salmon).

Helpful tips and tricks for homemade cream cheese schmear

  • The longer the yogurt strains, the thicker it will become!
  • The liquid whey that you get from the draining process can be used as a substitute for buttermilk, milk, or water can be used in bread, muffin, or cake recipes.
  • It keeps for about a week or so in an airtight container.
  • You could also use the cream cheese as a sour cream substitute.
  • Experiment with different fruits like blueberry and honey, or savory flavors like garlic and salmon!


  • 32 oz Plain Yogurt - Live, active probiotic
  • 5 medium-sized Strawberries, diced
  • 3 Jalapenos, diced
  • Dan-O’s Original Seasoning
  • Dan-O’s Crunchy Seasoning
  • Cheesecloth

Preparation Instructions

  1. Place a large strainer inside a mixing bowl.
  2. Layer the bottom of the strainer with cheesecloth.
  3. In another bowl, add yogurt.
  4. Dice jalapenos and strawberries and add to yogurt.
  5. Add both Dan-O’s seasonings.
  6. Mix thoroughly and pour into cheesecloth.
  7. Let sit refrigerated for 5 hours to drain whey.
  8. Remove excess whey from bowl and let sit refrigerated for 48 hours.
  9. After 48 hours remove from cheesecloth.
  10. Spread cream cheese on a bagel and top with Dan-O’s Crunchy Seasoning. Serve and enjoy!


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

My Cart
FREE shipping on all orders!
Contiguous US (Lower 48 states) only
Customers also bought

Your cart is empty

It's time to load up!

Save 15% on Your First Order Subscribe to our mailing list